(Capcom's primary storyline)
"Timmy did not mind the harsh light of four suns/Eyes require heads and he did not have one."
— Timmy's stanza in the Old Notebook
Timmy was one of five victims that were murdered by the Baker family whose bodies were stored in the basement.
Timmy arrived at the house where the Baker family used to reside some time in 2017 due to unknown reasons. The hint that leads the player to point at the pot of stew in the kitchen suggests that he was eaten; the note implies that he was decapitated and then cooked.